About First American Home Warranty
First American Home Warranty has operated since 1984 under the umbrella of one of America's most established financial services companies. This institutional backing provides financial security that smaller warranty providers cannot match. Their A+ BBB rating reflects a consistent track record of handling claims fairly. Coverage is comprehensive for the most common home systems and appliances, with no age limits applied to covered items.
Pros
- A+ BBB rating - among the highest of major providers
- Part of Fortune 500 First American Financial Corporation
- Strong financial stability and institutional backing
- Covers older appliances and systems with no age restrictions
- Established contractor network, particularly strong in Western states
Cons
- More limited availability outside the Western United States
- Less name recognition than the largest national providers
- Some exclusions for non-standard system configurations
What First American Home Warranty Covers
- HVAC systems
- plumbing
- electrical
- kitchen appliances
- water heater
- washer and dryer
- garage door opener
- doorbells and smoke detectors
Common First American Home Warranty Complaints
Like all home warranty companies, First American Home Warranty has received complaints from some customers. The most commonly reported issues include:
- Coverage availability and contractor networks vary significantly by region
- Some customers report difficulty navigating larger corporate claims process
- Limited contractor options in rural and suburban areas outside major metros
These complaints are common across the home warranty industry and do not necessarily reflect a systemic problem - they represent the experiences of a subset of policyholders in a large customer base. Reading recent reviews from verified customers on third-party review platforms gives the most current picture of service quality.
How to File a First American Home Warranty Claim
Call First American's claims line or submit online at firstam.com/warranty. Local contractors typically make initial contact within 24 to 48 hours of claim submission.
Is First American Home Warranty Worth It?
First American Home Warranty is a well-established home warranty provider with decades of industry experience. For homeowners whose covered systems are aging or whose homes lack a large repair reserve fund, a home warranty from First American - or a comparable provider - can provide significant financial protection.
The best way to determine whether First American Home Warranty is the right fit is to compare their current rates and coverage caps against alternatives. Call us at (805) 749-4065 for a free comparison or complete the quote form above.