American Home Shield vs First American Home Warranty

Which home warranty is right for your home? A detailed side-by-side comparison.

Get Your Free Home Warranty Quote

By submitting, you consent to receiving calls and texts from Home Warranty Now and its partners at the number provided, including by autodialer. Consent is not a condition of purchase. Reply STOP to opt out. Privacy Policy.

Overview

FeatureAmerican Home ShieldFirst American Home Warranty
Founded19711984
HeadquartersMemphis, TNSanta Ana, CA
BBB RatingBA+
Customer Reviews14,000+5,200+

American Home Shield

American Home Shield pioneered the home warranty industry and remains the market leader more than 50 years later. With a network of thousands of local contractors and multiple plan options, AHS handles everything from a broken AC in July to a leaking water heater in winter. Their coverage extends to systems and appliances regardless of age, which matters for homeowners with older homes where pre-existing wear is a concern.

Pros

  • Nation's largest home warranty company with 50+ years of experience
  • No age limit on covered systems and appliances
  • Available in all 50 states with a broad contractor network
  • Multiple plan tiers to match different budgets and needs
  • Covers unknown pre-existing conditions on most plans

Cons

  • Customer service wait times can be long during peak season
  • Contractor scheduling may take several days in high-demand periods
  • Some customers report claim denials for items deemed improperly maintained

First American Home Warranty

First American Home Warranty has operated since 1984 under the umbrella of one of America's most established financial services companies. This institutional backing provides financial security that smaller warranty providers cannot match. Their A+ BBB rating reflects a consistent track record of handling claims fairly. Coverage is comprehensive for the most common home systems and appliances, with no age limits applied to covered items.

Pros

  • A+ BBB rating - among the highest of major providers
  • Part of Fortune 500 First American Financial Corporation
  • Strong financial stability and institutional backing
  • Covers older appliances and systems with no age restrictions
  • Established contractor network, particularly strong in Western states

Cons

  • More limited availability outside the Western United States
  • Less name recognition than the largest national providers
  • Some exclusions for non-standard system configurations

Coverage Comparison

Coverage AreaAHSFirst American
HVAC systemsHVAC systemsHVAC systems
plumbingplumbingplumbing
electricalelectricalelectrical
kitchen applianceskitchen applianceskitchen appliances
washer and dryerwasher and dryerwater heater
refrigeratorrefrigeratorwasher and dryer
garage door openergarage door openergarage door opener
ceiling fansceiling fansdoorbells and smoke detectors

Which Should You Choose?

American Home Shield has been in the industry since 1971 and brings decades of experience and a large contractor network. First American Home Warranty, founded in 1984, offers strong coverage across the country.

The right choice depends on your priorities: if contractor network size and company history matter most, American Home Shield has a strong case. If customer satisfaction scores are your primary concern, compare recent reviews from verified customers on both platforms before deciding.

Get a free quote to see which provider offers the best rates for your specific home and location by calling (805) 749-4065 or completing the form above.

Ready to Protect Your Home?

Get a free quote in minutes. No inspection required.

Get My Free Quote